Click on a Page for More Details

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

2. Rice Without Rain Intro.

The novel we are starting is about Thailand in the 1970s.  It is about one girl's coming-of-age in a small town (sound familiar?).  She wants to be different from the people in her family and change the culture she lives in, while maintaining respect for her heritage.

Please post a COMMENT where you answer all of the questions below after reading the Foreword and doing some research online:
1. What happened at Thammasat University in 1976?
2. What are some pros and cons of the communist government in Thailand back then?
3. What kinds of problems are often faced by poor peasant farmers?
4. How did university students try to help the peasant farmers?

5.  Why does the student Jiranan say in the Foreword, "Naively, we thought that we could do anything, if only we tried hard enough?"

6. Do you agree or disagree that it is naive to believe you can do anything if you try?

Minfong with her three children, Danfung, MeiMei, and Chris   

Bonus Question:
What does Thai mean?


27 comments:

  1. 1. military massacred student protesters
    2. pro: they had an outstanding educational system. con: military leaders ruled Thailand.
    3. they faced high property taxes and were ruled by Commnists.
    4. the students protested the government.
    5. they were eventually decimated by the regime they were against.
    6. I believe that I will never be able to do somethings because I am restricted by my own abilities.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 6. I agree there, I also think we can't ever reach our full potential because our fears restrict us.

      Delete
  2. 1. There was a massacre of students and protestors for suspicion of communism.
    2. Pros of communisst goevernment is that it is very structured. A con is that it is very constricting to the way people live.
    3. They are treated like slum so they are taken advantage of for their money.
    4. They tried to pass reforms to lower taxes on the farmers.
    5. They thought that they didnt try hard enough to help the farmers.
    6. I agree because no one says you cant do anything. If you set your mind to it anything you can acomplish all.
    bonus: Thai means "Free"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 6. I agree because no one says you cant do anything. If you set your mind to it you can acomplish all.

      Delete
  3. 1.) The Military regained control with no warning a student demonstration was stormed by mobs and soldiers. It the massacre at least 46 students were killed and hundreds were wounded.
    2.) Pros is very structure and Cons is restricting on the way people live.
    3.)They are put at the bottom of the chain and cared for less than the others are.
    4.)They left.
    5.)They think that they could have tried harder but they didnt.
    6.)Disagree because i do think that if you do put your mind to something you can do anything you want.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. 1. The Military gain complete control and their was a massacre of students.
    2. Pro: Very structured. Con: Very controlling .
    3. The farmers have to pay a lot of rent. Mostly in money.
    4. The students help them fight for their freedom.
    5. In our country mostly we get what we want by protesting and having little groups or parties and just making the gov. see what we want. For them its completely different situations and gov. .
    6. I Disagree.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1. Thammasat University massacre
    2. Cons: the people have no say in what happens in the government. Pro: Very structured.
    3. Not enough money to pay for housing not enough food to eat, have to sell all the food they grow to even make any money.
    4. they helped organize farmer leaders.
    5. he said that so that everyone would feel better and have higher spirits.
    6. I think in some situations it is naive to say that we can do any thing when we try, but then it is better to say that so you aren't just giving up on every thing

    ReplyDelete
  8. 1. The Thammasat University massacre. It was an attack on students and protestors.
    2. A pro of the communist government is that they were very structured. And a con of the communist government is they were very restrictive on the way people lived.
    3. The problems the farmers often faced were that they had to pay high taxes and were usually taken advantage of.
    4. The university students passed reforms to lower the taxes for the farmers.
    5. I believe he said this because, he thought they didn't try hard enough.
    6. I believe you can do anything in life if you just believe in yourself and try hard enough.
    Bonus Question: Thai in Thailand means "free"

    ReplyDelete
  9. 1)The military came to the school and shot all the reformers and protesters.
    2)Pro~ Strong military means good defences;
    Con~ Military is often completely misused and misguided.
    3)Loss of land, VERY poor, and the government doesn't care for them, unless the peasents don't pay them.
    4)As they learned about democracy they decided to over throw the militant government, and travle around Thailand to help out the farmers.
    5)They thought that after taking over that the militant government would give up, and focused completely on helping, and not building a military of their own to repress the old military powers.
    6)I agree that it IS naive to believe you can do anything by trying, because you need skills, statagies, and goals to accomplish even the smallest tasks. However I could also disagree because you can't accomplish anything if you don't try.

    ReplyDelete
  10. 1. Thammasat University was invaded by right-wing mobs an soldiers killing nearly forty-six leading to a brutal massacre.
    2. Cons: The military regained all control with no warning, Pros: Society progressed.
    3. The farmers began to get taxed and had to go into the cities searching for jobs.
    4. The students began to protest by forming an outlawed Communist party.
    5. They thought they could do anything but was proved wrong quickly.
    6. I do believe that you can push your self onto certain things but there are going to be a things you can't do for some reason that either you or something else limits.

    ReplyDelete
  11. 1. The military regained total control, at least forty six students where killed, and hundreds badly wounded.

    2. Pros the communist government wasn't as bad as it is now.

    3. The peasant farmers are treated differently, and with less respect and don't get enough salary for their work.

    4. The students tried to do a petition to lower taxes on the workers.

    5. She thought that they didn't try hard enough in order to make what they were striving for happen.

    6. I don't think it is naive that you can do anything if you try. It's naive to do the contrary. To not try at all, because you are afraid of failure is naive. If you put that aside you can do it.

    Bonus: Thai: it means free!

    ReplyDelete
  12. 1.) military massacre of students and protestors.
    2.)Pro: government structure Con: very consisting of the way people live.
    3.) they are treated badly and people take advantage of them for money.
    4.) students protest the government.
    5.) they thought they didn't try hard enough.
    6.) not anything, but you can if you try hard enough. If it's within reason.

    ReplyDelete
  13. 1.) The Military had regain control with no warning a student demonstration was stormed by mobs and soldiers. It the massacre at least 46 students were killed and hundreds were wounded.
    2.) Pros is very structure and Cons are restricting on the way people live.
    3.)They are all put at the bottom of the chain and was very much cared for less than the others were.
    4.)They had left.
    5.)They think that they could have tried harder but they didnt.
    6.)I really Disagree because I believe if you set your mind on what you want to do you can do anything you want.

    ReplyDelete
  14. 1. the military had regain control with no warning a mob and soldiers the massacre had 46 students killed and hundreds were hurt

    2. Pros is very structure and cons are restricting on the way people live.

    3. They are all put at the bottom of the chain and was very much cared for less than the others were

    4.They had left the place

    5. They think that they could have tried way harder but in a way they did not

    6. No because i can not juts get up and fly out my chair

    ReplyDelete
  15. 1. The military regained total control at least forty six students where killed and hundreds badly wounded.
    2. Pro Very structured. Con they are very controlling.
    3. The farmers have to pay a lot of rent.
    4. The students protested
    5. She thought that they didn't try hard enough.
    6. I agree you can do anything if you trued your hardest.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. 1.The military regained in control, at least forty six students where killed
    2.Pro: Very structured. Con: Very controlling
    3.The problems the farmers often had were that they had to pay high taxes & were taken advantage of
    4.The students tried to do a petition to lower taxes on the workers
    5.they thought they didn't try enough
    6.Disagre

    ReplyDelete
  18. 1.the millitary went in to the school and murdered students for speaking out.
    2.there are pro and cons to there way of living
    3. The farmr were being taxed and couldnt pay for they crops cost and had to look for work other than in the fields
    4. They brought together a com. group
    5.it means they didnt try as hard enough as they thought they would
    6. yes and no i think if u beileve u can they go for it but dont make a crazy dream that u no u cant do and get all worked up jus to be let down

    ReplyDelete
  19. everl body on the football team that can move me must be a virile person because im a strong guy.

    ReplyDelete

Your comment must be school appropriate and on task, or it will be deleted.